When Therapy Isn’t Working: Dr. Stacey Krauss on Group Therapy, Intensive Outpatient Programs and Finding the Right Fit

Experience exceptional mental health treatment with the dedicated and skilled team at Transitions Counseling and Consulting. 

Our accredited outpatient services include a full range of treatment options for children, teens, and adults, ensuring you can receive continuous care from the same compassionate team as your needs change.

When Therapy Isn’t Working - Healthy teen life

Summary

On Healthy Teen Life, Dr. Stacey Krauss, CEO of Transitions Counseling and Consulting, spoke with host Leslie Rose about what teens and college students can do when therapy doesn’t seem to be helping. She shared why it’s okay to tell a therapist something isn’t working, how group programs like IOP and PHP differ from one hour a week of therapy, why the people in a group can be its biggest strength and how young people can find a good fit.

Key Takeaways

  • According to Dr. Krauss, two painful things can happen when therapy doesn’t work as hoped: people worry mental health care isn’t for them, or they blame themselves.
  • Telling a therapist that something isn’t working may feel rude, but Dr. Krauss says one brief, uncomfortable conversation can open the door to a better fit.
  • Therapy isn’t only one hour a week. As Dr. Krauss describes it, IOP groups typically meet two or three times a week for two to three hours, over about eight to 12 weeks.
  • In Dr. Krauss’s experience, the other people in a group are what many participants are most nervous about at first and often what they value most.
  • Dr. Krauss shares the idea that there’s no wrong front door to mental health care. The important thing is to take one step forward, even if it feels a little uncomfortable.

Listen to Dr. Stacey Krauss’s full Healthy Teen Life interview:
Listen to the podcast

What should a teen or college student do when therapy just isn’t working?

Most conversations about mental health focus on the first step: getting to therapy. Far fewer talk about what to do when therapy doesn’t help the way you hoped. According to Dr. Krauss, that gap matters, because one tough experience can keep people away from mental health care for months, years or even decades.

Dr. Stacey Krauss, Psy.D., ABPP, CEO of Transitions Counseling and Consulting, recently joined Leslie Rose on Healthy Teen Life for a practical conversation about that experience.

The episode, “When Therapy Isn’t Working, Do This,” explores what young people can do when they feel stuck in therapy. The conversation covers giving feedback to a therapist, group therapy, intensive outpatient and partial hospitalization programs, making time for care and how to find the right provider.

From Army Psychologist to Group Care for Teens and Young Adults

Leslie introduced Dr. Krauss as a double board-certified psychologist and Bronze Star recipient who led the U.S. Army’s largest behavioral health program at Fort Bragg.

Dr. Krauss says her team specializes in a certain type of group care, and many of the people they serve are teenagers and young adults.

As a psychologist, she says, talking about therapy is one of her favorite topics.

“Can you think of a single time you’ve ever heard anybody tell you what to do or what your options are if you’re going to therapy and you’re just not feeling better?” she asks. Much of the conversation, she notes, is about just getting to therapy, and not enough is about what happens if it doesn’t work the way you hoped.

The Two Painful Outcomes When Therapy Doesn’t Help

Dr. Krauss sees two especially painful outcomes when people don’t get the result they’re looking for in therapy:

  • They lose faith in mental health care: People worry that therapy, or the whole field of mental health, is not for them and can never be helpful.
  • They blame themselves: Maybe even more painful, people feel it is their fault that therapy isn’t working, as though they’re doing it wrong.

Leslie added that one experience can make or break whether someone keeps going. Maybe you didn’t click with the person you were meeting with, or they weren’t getting at what you wanted to talk about.

Dr. Krauss offered an analogy. If you have a bad experience with a dentist, it’s just that dentist. It won’t stop you from getting your teeth cleaned for the rest of your life.

“But if you have a tough experience with a mental health provider, it’s all of us.”

It may be months, years or even decades, she says, before someone finds the courage to try again.

Why It’s Okay to Tell Your Therapist Something Isn’t Working

Part of the problem, Dr. Krauss believes, is that not enough time is spent helping people understand that it’s okay to give feedback when therapy isn’t working well, even though it can feel rude.

“The therapist’s job is to help you to get the result that you need, that you’re looking for and that you deserve,” she says. And that’s true even if that therapist isn’t the right fit.

Leslie, who sees the same thing as a coach, shared a few ways teens can speak up:

  • “This isn’t working for me.”
  • “I don’t understand where we’re going with this.”
  • “I’m feeling like you’re not hearing what my concern is.”

Dr. Krauss points out that there are very few relationships where you have the license to give feedback as directly as you do with a coach or therapist. Normally, the social contract says to be polite and just not come back. Instead, she encourages having “one brief, uncomfortable conversation” that can lead to a much better experience.

Therapy Isn’t Only One Hour a Week

Many people picture therapy as one hour a week, either in an office or on a computer by telehealth. That’s also what we see on TV: two people sitting across from each other for an hour.

But Dr. Krauss says there are actually many different types of care that might be a better fit, depending on what’s happening for you.

She explains that many teen and young adult clients felt one hour a week alone with a therapist wasn’t a great fit, and that the group setting was a better fit for them. They simply hadn’t known group care was an option.

Some of the more specialized types of group care are called intensive outpatient programs (IOP) and partial hospitalization programs (PHP). Dr. Krauss notes that PHP is “kind of a misnomer because there’s no hospital involved.” Instead, people get the same number of hours of care they would in a hospital.

According to Dr. Krauss, these programs are meant to help teens and young adults build the skills of therapy much more quickly than the one-hour-a-week pace of traditional therapy or coaching.

How IOP Changes the Pace of Care

Dr. Krauss gave an example. Imagine someone who feels so anxious about going to class each day that they’re struggling to get started and falling behind on homework.

She explains that, according to research, one hour of therapy per week can help over time, but at a much slower pace. An IOP group meets multiple days a week and focuses on practicing skills, which she says gives people more chances to start using new skills in their everyday lives.

As Dr. Krauss describes it, a typical IOP looks like this:

  • Frequency: Two or three sessions per week.
  • Session length: Between two and three hours each.
  • Length of the program: About eight to 12 weeks, compared with individual therapy that might progress over 24 to 40 or more weeks.

She compares it to training for a big race. If you need 30 training sessions, you could work out once a month for 30 months or three times a week for a couple of months. Practicing closer together means more feedback and support right away, which makes it easier to bring skills into real life instead of leaving them in the therapy office.

Why Group Can Feel Less Draining Than One-on-One

Leslie asked about the mental fatigue some teens may feel after a long stretch of therapy. Dr. Krauss explained that in regular therapy, nearly all the attention and responsibility falls on the client. For 53 minutes of the hour, the spotlight is on you, and therapy is real work.

In a group, it becomes a shared activity. You learn from many examples, including other members’ lived experience, not just your therapist’s. Because group therapy tends to focus on skill building, it can also be fun. There’s an element of learning together, almost like a team sport, with other people to cheer you on.

The therapist who leads the group helps everyone take part in learning how to use each skill.

What If Group Therapy Sounds Scary?

Many teens worry they’ll be put on the spot or judged in a group. Dr. Krauss understands that fear, including the worry that someone will push you to share before you’re ready.

That’s why structure matters. As she puts it, “groups with rules rule.” The goal, she explains, is to help everyone feel safe and confident in the group.

She compares group to “the mental health version of having a gym buddy.” When someone is expecting you, you show up, even on days you don’t feel like it.

Before starting, she says, people are usually most worried about the other members, so her team encourages them to try it for a week. By and large, most then say the other people are the best thing in the group.

“The thing that makes groups so scary is also what makes them so great.”

Part of the reason, Dr. Krauss believes, is that peers have no agenda. When peers who have no reason to be nice to you tell you they’re glad you’re there, it can reach you differently than it does from a professional. Many young people also realize they aren’t the only ones who feel the way they do. In her words, it’s like discovering “I’m not special in the best way possible.”

What If You Don’t Have Time?

Busy teens and college students often say they don’t have time for a program that meets several times a week. Dr. Krauss calls that a completely fair question, and the most common one her team hears.

Her response is to ask another question: “How much time is what you’re struggling with taking from your life right now?”

That could be time spent replaying something embarrassing you said or feeling so overwhelmed that you keep procrastinating on assignments. When you add it up, she says, the math of investing time in care can start to look pretty efficient.

Therapy does take time, she acknowledges, but it also has the very real possibility of giving time back. And what you learn in therapy, in coaching or in a group setting can be used now, and “it’s also yours for the rest of your life.”

Is Group Therapy Right for You?

Dr. Krauss says a small number of people simply learn best in groups. For most others, she looks for a few clear signs that group therapy might be a good fit:

  • Someone has tried therapy, psychiatry or both and hasn’t gotten enough relief, or the relief didn’t last.
  • Someone feels better right after a session, but by Friday or Saturday, feelings like anxiety, low mood, trouble sleeping or negative thoughts about themselves come back.
  • What someone is struggling with is really getting in the way of their life, and their life is starting to feel smaller.

In those cases, she says, it can make sense to increase the pace of care, with the goal of helping young people get back to being teenagers and young adults.

Individual therapy still has an important role. Dr. Krauss explains that deeply personal, painful experiences are usually best explored one-on-one, where you can go as deep as you need to. Many people use group therapy to build coping skills first, so they feel steadier before doing that more personal work. She adds that most people her team works with stay for a short period of individual therapy after finishing group.

Transitions offers a teen intensive outpatient program, an adult intensive outpatient program, a partial hospitalization program for teens and group therapy. Availability depends on location and individual needs.

For more, read Transitions’ guides on how to know if therapy is actually working and why to choose an intensive outpatient program over standard outpatient therapy.

How Teens and Families Can Find the Right Fit

So where should a teen, college student or parent start? Dr. Krauss suggests a few practical places to look:

  • Search online for “group therapy near me” or “therapy near me.”
  • Check your insurance company’s website for providers who accept your plan.
  • Look for a location you can realistically get to, or a telehealth option.
  • Ask friends, family members or your primary care provider who they trust.
  • Start with your school or college counseling center.

She also encourages looking up publicly available information, such as reviews, licenses and accreditation. And you don’t have to commit to the first person you meet. “You can interview as many of us as you want,” she tells Leslie.

Dr. Krauss shared a phrase she recently heard: there’s “no wrong front door to mental health care.”

“So don’t worry so much about opening the exact right door in your first time. Just pick one and open it.”

If you or someone you love is in crisis or having thoughts of suicide, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, or call 911 in an emergency.

Dr. Krauss’s Closing Advice for Teens and Young Adults

As the conversation wrapped up, Dr. Krauss shared a few final ideas:

  • It doesn’t have to be perfect: She says the most important thing is not to worry about getting every piece of the logistics right, but to “move your arms and legs forward.”
  • Take one meaningful step: Trust that you’ll figure out the process over time, even if the first step feels a little uncomfortable.
  • Picture your future self: Imagine where you could be six or 12 months from now if therapy has been helpful, and let that vision help you move forward.
  • Know that it takes courage: Speaking for coaches and therapists everywhere, she tells people taking that first step, “we think you’re really brave for doing it.”

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Dr. Stacey Krauss?

Dr. Stacey Krauss, Psy.D., ABPP, is CEO of Transitions Counseling and Consulting. She served for 10 years as an active-duty U.S. Army psychologist and has led Transitions since 2021.

What should you do if therapy isn’t working?

Dr. Krauss encourages people to tell their therapist directly, even if it feels uncomfortable. A therapist’s job is to help you get the result you’re looking for, even if they aren’t the right fit.

How is IOP different from weekly therapy?

As Dr. Krauss describes it, IOP is group-based care that typically meets two or three times a week for two to three hours per session, over about eight to 12 weeks. It focuses on building skills at a faster pace than one hour a week of individual therapy.

Where can teens and college students look for group therapy?

Dr. Krauss suggests searching online, checking your insurance company’s website, asking people you trust (including your primary care provider) and reaching out to your school or college counseling center.

What services does Transitions Counseling and Consulting provide?

Transitions Counseling and Consulting offers mental health services for people of all ages in Arizona and Texas. Services include individual counseling and therapy, group therapy, relationship and couples counseling, psychiatry and medication management, intensive outpatient programs for teens and adults and a partial hospitalization program for teens, with telehealth available when appropriate. Availability depends on location and individual needs.

Listen to Dr. Stacey Krauss on Healthy Teen Life

The full Healthy Teen Life conversation goes deeper into what to do when therapy isn’t working, how group therapy and intensive outpatient programs work and how teens and young adults can find care that fits their lives.

Listen to the full interview with Dr. Stacey Krauss

About Dr. Stacey Krauss

Stacey Krauss, Psy.D., ABPP, is CEO of Transitions Counseling and Consulting. She served for 10 years as an active-duty U.S. Army psychologist and is board certified in both Clinical Psychology and Business and Organizational Consulting Psychology.

Learn more about Dr. Stacey Krauss and her background.

Her professional experience includes executive-level roles leading behavioral health teams for the Department of Defense and designing and directing nationally accredited training programs for future psychologists. She is licensed to practice in Arizona and Texas.

Today, she leads Transitions Counseling and Consulting’s work to expand access to mental health care for children, teens, adults and families in Arizona and Texas.

Find Mental Health Support for Your Family

Transitions Counseling and Consulting offers mental health services for children, teens, adults, couples and families in Arizona and Texas, with telehealth available when appropriate. Contact Transitions or call (602) 363-0629 to schedule an appointment or ask which services fit your needs.

At Transitions Counseling and Consulting, we provide compassionate, evidence-based mental health care for children, teens, and adults. Our personalized treatment options help individuals and families find the support they need to improve their mental health and move forward with confidence. Explore our services to learn how we can help.

How We Can Help You

We tailor treatment to fit your unique needs. Our team offers the full continuum of outpatient therapy services for the whole family. This means you can work with the same team as your treatment needs change over time.